In Central Indiana, a “Manhattan” Is an Open-Faced Turkey Sandwich with Mashed Potatoes and Gravy

For many Hoosiers, a Manhattan is an open-faced sandwich of turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, and gravy, eaten with a knife and fork. When Mary from Indianapolis, Indiana, used the term at a funeral dinner in Minnesota, her aunt thought she was referring to a cocktail, while another guest pictured New York City. In parts of Minnesota, similar open-faced sandwiches are called commercials. The sandwich name Manhattan or Turkey Manhattan is specific to central Indiana, and one story goes that workers from a military factory there went to Manhattan to learn gunsights and brought back the sandwich named after the place. Menus from the early 1900s in Wisconsin and New York mention a different Manhattan consisting of fried egg, minced ham, and onion, later known as a Denver or Western. This is part of a complete episode.

Transcript of “In Central Indiana, a “Manhattan” Is an Open-Faced Turkey Sandwich with Mashed Potatoes and Gravy”

Hi.

You have A Way with Words.

Hi.

This is Mary, and I’m calling from Indiana.

Well, welcome to the show, Mary.

What can we do for you today?

So I have a little bit of a story.

I was attending my uncle’s funeral in Minnesota, and the after funeral dinner menu consisted of traditional Thanksgiving meal.

And one of my cousins made an open-faced sandwich of turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, and gravy.

And I said, oh, you’ve made a Manhattan, and everyone looked puzzled.

So my aunt overheard this and said, oh, you like to share a Manhattan with me?

And she was meaning the cocktail.

And another one said, oh, you’re going to Manhattan?

I wanna go.

So it struck me as funny that in that one instance, we were all thinking that Manhattan meant different things.

Yeah.

That’s fantastic.

I love the…

I love that when you get this weird kind of friction from the different meanings of a word.

So so let’s talk about this.

So where were you, what city or state when you had this encounter?

So I was in Minnesota Ok.

In Mankato.

Ok.

Ok.

And nobody else really seemed to know the Manhattan sandwich you were talking about?

No.

I’ve since learned that they call open faced sandwiches In Minnesota, they call’ commercials.

Yeah.

Parts of Minnesota, they definitely do a hot beef commercial and other similar names.

Yeah.

Mhmm.

And Mary, you said you were from Indiana.

Where in Indiana?

I’m from Indianapolis, Indiana.

Ok.

So more central than that’s that’s all clicking here for us.

Yep.

So there’s a couple interesting things here.

One, we just have to acknowledge how far this word Manhattan has traveled from being the name of a native American group on the Island Of Manhattan centuries ago to being a place for European settlers and then eventually becoming the name for food and other things that kind of give a taste of a suggestion, a connotation of big city life or fashion or, you know, being with it and trendy.

So that’s kind of what’s happening with these Manhattan names.

But the story of the Manhattan sandwich, I think, is probably the most interesting of the items that you mentioned.

Not least because the Manhattan sandwich is so specific to Central Indiana.

Now, it has popped up here and there in other states, but for the most part, belongs to Central Indiana and has for a long time.

Now, not the kind of food, because putting meat and gravy on toast shows up, you know, in the eighteen seventies, But the name of it as a beef Manhattan or the turkey Manhattan.

And so, let me see if this is how you make yours merry.

So you’ve got slices of bread or toast, perhaps cut into triangles.

You put mashed potatoes, perhaps scooped with an ice cream scoop, a little mountains of them in the middle, maybe right where the toast is cut, and then pour…

Put meat on there, and lots of gravy from that meat over everything.

Correct.

Ok.

And you…

You’re not really a sandwich you eat with your hands.

Right?

This is kind of a knife and fork deal.

Yeah.

Otherwise, you’re just gonna get gravy everywhere.

Yeah.

So it’s it’s really interesting.

So it shows up early nineteen hundreds in menus in Wisconsin and New York featured a different Manhattan sandwich, very different.

Fried egg, minced ham and onion.

Something that later became known as a Denver or Western in other places.

But this particular sandwich we’re talking about here with the toast and the mashed potatoes and the meat and the gravy, probably did start in New York City.

And there’s a story that they tell in Indiana about people who worked at a military factory in Indiana going to Manhattan and encountering the sandwich and bringing it back.

They went to Manhattan to learn how to make gunsights.

And then they came back with that new knowledge and this sandwich and called it the Manhattan after the place where they learned about it.’

Cause it does look like there are fantastic archives of menus at the New York Public Library.

So we can do some tracking of food items around the country by when they first start to appear in restaurant menus.

But, of course, we can also look at newspaper ads and see what they’re what they’re promoting.

That’s incredible.

I think that that’s amazing.

And I just, again, thought that it was so interesting, you know, for an…

Someone from Indiana to be going to Minnesota and and hearing the three different ways that that can be Yeah.

English is That can be determined.

Can you imagine if you weren’t a native speaker how much more difficult that would be?

Oh my gosh.

Wow.

Well, Mary, thanks for sharing that story.

That’s a great one.

Aw.

Thank you so much.

I appreciate it.

You take care now.

Bye-bye.

You too.

Bye-bye.

Share your stories about language with us.

(877-929-9673.

Join the discussion

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More from this show