gone pecan n. a person who is doomed, defeated, or beyond rescue; a goner. Editorial Note: As noted in the 2003 citation, pecan is pronounced in this expression to rhyme with gone, so it’s something like “puh-KAHN” rather than “PEE-kann,” which is another common pronunciation of pecan used throughout the United States. This expression is particularly common in Louisiana. Similar terms given by the Dictionary of American Regional English are gone goose, gone gosling, gone coon, and gone beaver. (source: Double-Tongued Dictionary)
Further reading
An upscuddle, also spelled upscuttle, is defined in both the Dictionary of American Regional English and the Dictionary of Southern Appalachian English (Bookshop|Amazon) as a type of quarrel. A 1913 reference uses the term this way: “If they...
Amid court-ordered busing in the 1970s, a middle-school teacher tried to distract her nervous students on the first day of class with this strange assignment: find a monarch caterpillar. The result? A memorable lesson in the miracle of metamorphosis...
Anyone can grasp the meaning from the context. What I’d like to know is the origin, please.
Like most words, the origin is unknown. Also, like most words, if we did know the origin it would probably be both useless and boring.
I grew up with this phrase – it was one of my father’s favorites. I thought he was the only one to actually use it, but the fact that we’re from Louisiana (he’s from Lake Charles, in particular) jibes well with the citation above. We really do have a lot of pecans. And indeed, “puh-KAHN” is how we pronounce it. “PEE-can” is for yankees, and hearing it drives us batty. Especially if it has that super-nasal, midwestern “a” sound. Yeesh.
So the pecan trees that I can’t get to grow down in the Ozarks are a gone pecan, eh? That works for me.
“Like most words, the origin is unknown. Also, like most words, if we did know the origin it would probably be both useless and boring.”
Could two statements be more incorrect?
Most English words *can* be traced back to their ancestors in an older language, and the Oxford English Dictionary cites the first known usage of every word in every sense, giving a history of each word’s evolution for almost 1000 years. (Of course, the origins of *those* essentially foreign roots is in most cases a mystery, but that is not what you were talking about.)
As to your suggestion that word origins are “useless and boring”—you’re just nuts.
You’re talking completely out of your ass, Adam. As someone who has worked for Oxford University Press as a lexicographer and dictionary editor and knows a dozen OED editors professionally and personally, including etymologists, I can tell you with no equivocation that the OED cites are in no way conclusive nor exhaustive. Most terms and expressions have not been, cannot be, and will never be traced back to their absolute origins, even in the written record. The best we have is educated guesswork and traces in an incomplete written record. Not only that, but the OED is nowhere near complete: it does not have “every” word nor “every” sense of the words it does have. It is, as every OED editor will tell you, an incomplete work in progress. You’d best go somewhere else to tell people how to suck eggs.
The origin has to do with the rhyme it creates in southern Louisiana. “Gone Pecan,” much like the rhyme “later alligator,” the alliteration “dead as a door nail,” or the LSU football cheer “hot boudin, cold cous-cous, come on Tigers, push, push, push!”