Notifications
Clear all

The burgeoning INFANTesimal

8 Posts
2 Users
0 Reactions
1 Views
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

I've been hearing it for some time, but chalked it up to quick speech: infinitesimal pronounced as INFANTesimal . OK, so maybe the crowd I hang out with uses the word infinitesimal more than they should. Still, I hear it a lot.

I heard it mispronounced this morning on a podcast from the mouth of a scientist speaking slowly and carefully -- IN-FAN-TES-I-MAL.

I can't remember the last time I heard it pronounced fully. A web search -- even Google books -- shows up some seemingly unintended misspellings as infantesimal.

End of rant.

7 Replies
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

Yeah, I've been hearing that more often too. Don't like it, but totally understand it. Ngrams was a bust, so this usage must be newer than 2000. Sounds to me like one of those many instances where people who hear the word just assume the spelling (and pronunciation). I mean, it kinda makes sense ... if infinitesimal means "something very small" then the substitution of "infant" for "infinite" seems like a natural error. Not unlike how, as a child, I thought the "Taj Mahal" was the "Tashma Hall" ... until I saw it in print and realized the error of my ways.

I think it's more than just "quick speech," as Glenn suggests. I think it's more a matter of learning the language by hearing rather than reading.   

Reply
deaconB
Posts: 742
(@deke)
Member
Joined: 12 years ago

Ngrams aren't likely to show it because most people have spell-check.

I'm less annoyed by the "infantesimal" pronunciation (although I hear more "infantessmal") than I am by newscritters talking about sexual "harris mint" because the latter is mostly deliberate, by those who should know better.

My brother's GPS talks of "toely-dough", that city in NW Ohio.  Native American names confuse people, too. I have heard ignorant newscasters talk of "wuh bptch he" (Ouacaxhe State Park is pronounced "Wabash"), "wuh WASS sea" (Lake Wawasee is pronounced "Wah Wah Sea") and "POKE a gone" (Pokagon State Park is pronounced "Poe KAY gun").

Forty years ago, the morning newspaper in Fort Wayne did a front page story about the availani;ity of livestock feed, in which they spelled it "Alphalpha" instead of "alfalfa".  Google finds 44,100,000 pages with "Adolph Hitler" versus only 2,340,000 for the correct spelling of "Adolf Hitler"

Reply
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

deaconB said:  Ngrams aren’t likely to show it because most people have spell-check.

Spell-check first arrived for personal computers in 1980, according to Wiki. Until Ngrams scans their corpus beyond 2000, we won't likely see that kind of filtering. But you make a good point about Ngrams ... this result only goes to 2008 (the default was 2000). I entered 2014 and it reset to 2008. Obviously a work in progress.

A Google search of "infantesimal" yields a mere 4,370 hits, whereas "infinitesimal" yields 4,290,000. This new spelling is an aberration at best. I doubt it will ever become part of the language.

Reply
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

I may be misunderstanding Ngrams but doesn't it only look at published material?  If that is true, then nearly all published works would have editors who most likely would catch an error like this.  Considering that, 4370 may seem like a lot.  Self editing or bad editing could account for that.

Reply
Page 1 / 2