In freshman English I was admonished to never pluralize the noun-as-adjective.
But in real life, the plural form is dominant : 'Weapons system', Â 'Taxes service', 'Jobs program', etc. etc...
Should I stick with my formal education or go with the flow?
I've never been sure about this. Â In the computer world we have "systems programming" and "applications programming"; it seems to me the terms would be exactly as clear without the plural form, but unlike you I was never formally taught that the plural was wrong so on the rare occasions when I stare at them, trying to figure out whether it makes any difference, I always end up shrugging and moving on.
Are there any examples where it makes a difference? Â Is there any phrase where horses breeding means something different from horse breeding (plug in your own nouns here)? Â Maybe that would shed some light on this question.
This has been one of my pet peeves ever since Martha Stewart Living magazine started saying "See the Recipes section." Â The Chicago Manual of Style (sections 5.22, 7.25) calls these attributive nouns. If the singular can cover the plural, it works: tax attorney. If the meaning could be ambiguous, maybe use the plural: antiques store (not an antique, old, store) (?). Chicago also adds the apostrophe if the possessive is meant: workers' party. (Often the apostrophe gets dropped because it's a pain to know where to put it -- Worker's Party or Workers' Party?). Â If this has been discussed on the show, which episode was it?
I don't recall it on the show, but it was discussed somewhat at this forum at this link:
https://waywordradio.org/discussion/topics/baby-singular/?value=baby&type=1&include=1&search=1
Bob Bridges said:
...Is there any phrase where horses breeding means something different from horse breeding (plug in your own nouns here)? Â Maybe that would shed some light on this question.
This is a farm boy's take on the above that are different to me. My dad's first cousin did horse breeding on his farm. The act of copulation between a stallion and a mare could be called horses breeding.
Emmett