Light year
 
Notifications
Clear all

Light year

Posts: 551
Topic starter
(@robert)
Member
Joined: 14 years ago

It happens again! This time in 'The Age of Miracles' by Karen Thompson Walker, p. 93:
'I wanted to think that somewhere on the other end of time, a hundred light-years from then, someone else, some distant future creature might be looking back...'

The author might say that it's intentional, but that would be very lame.


3 Replies
Posts: 239
(@mrafee)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago

Yes. Once in one of our classes we were supposed to write a short story and one of my classmates had used 'light-year' exactly the same way as in the text you mentioned. When I said that 'light-year' is measuring distance, he said, "I now. But this is fiction and I've used it for time'! His story was, in fact, a short short story and the only way I could think was that he had made a mistake.( The definition alteration had not been well justified.)


Reply
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

Yeah, you can't change the meaning of words just because you're writing fiction. Β  You can make up words, if you want to, or terms. Β  You can even, if you want to be confusing, use an existing term and give it a new meaning. Β  But in that case you must make it clear to the reader that that's what you've done; otherwise the reader will persist in believing what we actually do believe, that both writers simply made a mistake.

And anyway, how would "a hundred years from then" quality as "the other end of time"? Β  (Just being querulous.)


Reply
Posts: 551
Topic starter
(@robert)
Member
Joined: 14 years ago

Late in the book, the father of the teenage girl uses it for distance.
I almost see the author's sly smile.
Anyway, it is a good sci-fi, just out, first book by this author. (But not if you don't like sad stuffs.)


Reply

Recent posts