Notifications
Clear all

Impeach

Posts: 99
Topic starter
(@torpeau)
Member
Joined: 16 years ago

In school we were always corrected when we confused being impeached with being run out of office. Several times in recent years I have read or heard the word used improperly by the news media. I look up the word in modern dictionaries, but impeach still seems to mean to to accuse of misconduct, etc.


13 Replies
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

Yeah, I agree. Β  But I think that confusion has been going on quite a while, not just in the past few years. Β  I suppose the talking heads of today were, a few decade ago, the children in school who never quite took the lesson.


Reply
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

I also agree. When one "impeaches a witness" all it means is to discredit their testimony. Has nothing to do with being run out of office. When you "impeach a president" (or any elected official) you formally call their suitability for office into question, and that could be a precursor to being run out of office. At least that's the way I understand the meaning.


Reply
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

Just to be unnecessarily picky, I use "discredit" to mean, roughly, "prove unreliable". Β  "Impeach" means something closer to "impugn", ie to accuse; proof is a separate matter. Β  So if I impeach a witness, I've accused him of being unreliable; if I discredit the witness, I've convinced others he's unreliable, too. Β  It's kind of like the distinction between denying charges against me, and refuting them.


Reply
Posts: 99
Topic starter
(@torpeau)
Member
Joined: 16 years ago

Heimhenge said
I also agree. When one "impeaches a witness" all it means is to discredit their testimony. Has nothing to do with being run out of office. When you "impeach a president" (or any elected official) you formally call their suitability for office into question, and that could be a precursor to being run out of office. At least that's the way I understand the meaning.

With the president of Brazil being in the news a lot recently, "impeachment" is alsoΒ in the news. Β Frankly, it appears to used as meaning removing from office based on the context.

Impugning someone's integrity or accusing of wrongdoing is simply not the same thing as ousting from office Β -- two very different things. Β After all, Pres. Clinton was impeached, but Al Gore did not assume the office of the presidency.


Reply
Page 1 / 3

Recent posts