Discussion Forum (Archived)
Guest
I think I've spotted a trend.
Yeah-no is an odd mixed message. Heard mainly from radio talkshow types, but also in real life.
Two radio examples:
"Yeah-no, you've got a problem."
"Yeah-no, I was thinking along the same lines."
Real life example. Two Safeway employees chatting about scheduling:
"Yeah-no, I see what he means."
It's not spoken as a two-syllable word; it's four beats, with equal pauses.
Yeah / / No / / I was thinking etc.
May be a recent variant on a longer and broader trend toward starting positive statements with a simple No, as in "No, I think that's exactly right." There are circumstances where the No would make sense, as in answering a negatively phrased question, but it usually happens in a context where it's completely uncalled for.
I've been hearing that for years, maybe since the 90s. Certainly, a grammatically correct sentence can begin with "Yes, no ..." but I think in most cases it's just careless and colloquial usage and not grammatically correct (like some of the examples cited by polistra). In those cases, the "yeah" or "yes" serves more as an acknowledgment of the original question/comment ... maybe even as a place-holder like "Umm" or "Hmm" or "Actually."
If a USAF pilot receives directions from the tower, normally he replies "Roger, Wilco"
But what if there's a good reason, which the tower may not be aware of? For instance, I can't circle in a holding pattern, I* have less than 2 minutes of fuel left. Would he say "Roger, No Joy"?
I think "Yes, no, it's not that" is short for "Yes, I heard what you said, No, I disagree with you."
Mileage may vary.
Martha Barnette
Grant Barrett
Grant Barrett
1 Guest(s)