Notifications
Clear all

Poor grammar is bad

9 Posts
3 Users
0 Reactions
0 Views
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

First, here is a blog posting in the Harvard Business Review (hbr.org) by someone who administers grammar tests to prospective employees, explaining why
I Won't Hire People Who Use Poor Grammar.

Second, I want to peeve about using poor simply to mean bad.

A person who eats too much has a bad diet, but not necessarily a poor one. A diet can be poor in nutrition, or poor in iron. That would also be a bad diet.

A doctor can be poor if she has made unwise investments, or if her mother recently died. If she accidentally overdoses a patient, she is a bad doctor, and not a poor one.

For me the distinctive of adjectival poor is that the noun must lack something. If it is bad, it has to be bad in a particular way, in the particular of lacking. So, a person could employ a poor vocabulary, lacking apt words, repetition of the same words. But poor grammar?

I don't think bad grammar lacks a particular quality, so what would make it poor? No subjunctive? No past tense? No plurals? No articles? I have it. Subject-verb alignment!

It really annoys me to see poor used adjectivally as a blanket synonym for bad. So it is ironic to me that the title of the article is "I Won't Hire People Who Use Poor Grammar." (Didn't we once discuss a variant of Murphy's Law stating the more vitriol in your correcting someone's language, the greater your odds of making a language mistake within the correction?)

Am I alone in disliking this watered-down use of poor?

8 Replies
Posts: 1532
Admin
(@grantbarrett)
Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Did you see Geoff Pullum's response to that piece? It's somewhat tongue-in-cheek in its tone, but he makes some good (though for him, the same as usual) points, key among them the misuse of the word "grammar."

I don't feel what you're feeling about "poor," but here it's definitely weaselly shorthand for "disagrees with my opinions on how things should be."

Reply
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

Hey, Grant! I didn't see it. I got a link to the article via a LinkedIn spam. I was on the train and bored ... . I look forward to seeing the response.

BTW, I'm getting used to the new website. Change is always a shock, but I think I will like it much better now.

Reply
Posts: 0
Guest
(@Anonymous)
Joined: 1 second ago

Grant Barrett said
"poor," ... weaselly shorthand for "disagrees with my opinions on how things should be."

Should it be 'disagreeing...' ? because poor is adjective.
English is a mindfield, no, minefield.

Reply
Posts: 238
(@mrafee)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago

RobertB, you seem to have missed the point.

Grant meant: poor=disagrees with my opinion... .

Reply
Page 1 / 2